Hopes for Negotiations

The Kerry Peace Initiative was based on the following considerations -

  • The occupation of the West Bank costs Israel dearly -
    • Young Israelis were conscripted, brutalised, injured and sometimes killed. Increasing numbers were evading military service.
    • The settlements had to be heavily subsidised, at the expense of Israeli taxpayers
    • Because of the occupation, Israel was losing international support.
  • The conditions for a two-state solution were widely understood, so negotiators could be committed to reaching a final agreement, as distinct from an interim agreement, within nine months.
  • The Palestinians had deferred the pursuit of UN recognition, and application to the International Criminal Court, to avoid impeding negotiations.
  • Hamas, which had spearheaded Palestinian opposition to negotiations, had been weakened by the suppression of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt.
  • The ruling Israeli coalition was divided, and included Hawks and Doves. If the centre-right coalition rejected reasonable peace proposals a centre-left coalition could be formed without an immediate general election. The Knesset opposition leader, had promised to join Netanyahu's coalition if a peace deal depended on it.
  • The EU had offered valuable incentives for a peace agreement.
  • Anxiety over Iranian nuclear ambitions might have encouraged the Israeli government to settle quickly with the Palestinians.
  • The Separation Wall, albeit largely built on Palestinian soil, marked a clear distinction between Israel and Palestine. Only extremists could still claim that areas east of the Wall were part of Israel. This implied Israeli acceptance of a separate Palestinian State subject, of course, to provision for Israeli security.

Why did the talks fail?

Consider also:

Boycott Help for Palestinians Nuclear-free Middle East Prophets and Reconcilers Time Line